Why Can't S Waves Travel Through Liquids?

Blog › Earth Science Explained

· by Julia Berens · 5 min read

Why can't S waves travel through liquids? An S wave moves material sideways as it passes, and it can keep going only if that sideways shift produces an elastic push back. Solid rock can provide that push. A liquid can resist being squeezed, but it flows when neighboring layers are pushed sideways past one another. That difference explains why earthquake stations can record waves that crossed Earth's outer core without recording any wave that crossed it as an S wave.

Why can't S waves travel through liquids?

The S in S wave stands for secondary: in typical earthquake records, S waves arrive after the faster primary, or P, waves. An S wave is a shear wave. Imagine a pulse traveling left to right through a block of rock while tiny portions of the rock move up and down. The motion of the material is perpendicular to the direction the pulse travels. The rock does not travel across the block with the pulse. Each portion moves briefly as the disturbance passes.

To picture shear, draw a square on the side of a soft rubber eraser. Hold the bottom still and push the top sideways. The square slants into a parallelogram. Let go, and the eraser tends to recover its original shape. That tendency is what lets a sideways disturbance move through a solid: a displaced portion pulls on its neighbors, which in turn pull on the next portions.

Now drag a flat spoon across the surface of a bowl of water. The spoon pulls some water along, and the water's viscosity helps transfer that motion to nearby water. But when you stop, the water doesn't try to restore the original positions of its layers the way the eraser does. Viscosity resists the rate at which layers slide past each other. It does not provide the elastic restoring force needed to carry an S wave through the bulk liquid.

Shear stiffness and compression stiffness

Seismologists express the difference with a property called the shear modulus, represented here by G. It measures a material's elastic resistance to a change in shape caused by shear. In a simple elastic model, the S wave speed, vS, depends on the shear modulus and the density, ρ:

vS = (G / ρ)1/2

For the liquid outer core at earthquake wave periods, the shear modulus is effectively zero. The equation then gives zero S wave speed. That does not mean the wave inches through the core or waits at the boundary. It means there is no propagating S wave in the liquid. Density affects S wave speed where shear waves can travel, but density alone cannot tell you whether they can travel at all.

Compression is different. Squeeze a sealed syringe full of water with no air inside and the plunger barely moves. The water resists a change in volume even though it takes the shape of its container. In a P wave, material moves back and forth along the direction the wave travels, producing alternating compression and expansion. Because liquids resist compression, they can carry P waves. Sound traveling through water is another example of a compression wave in a liquid.

The missing arrivals on earthquake records

After an earthquake, seismologists can compare arrival times at stations around the world. They often describe a station's distance from the earthquake as an angle measured at Earth's center: a station at the point directly opposite the earthquake's epicenter is 180 degrees away. As that angle increases, a direct seismic wave generally follows a path that reaches deeper into Earth.

Direct S arrivals disappear at angular distances of roughly 103 degrees and beyond, where paths would have to cross the outer core to reach the stations as direct S waves. This is the direct S wave shadow zone. A shadow zone does not mean the ground stays still. It means a particular kind of arrival is missing. Stations there can still detect other waves from the same earthquake.

P waves show a different pattern. They bend sharply at the boundary between the mantle and the outer core because their speed changes there. This refraction leaves a direct P wave shadow zone at roughly 103 to 142 degrees. Farther away, stations can again record P waves that traveled through the core. The U.S. Geological Survey's guide to Earth's interior describes how seismic waves reveal layers we cannot observe directly.

How scientists tested the liquid core explanation

A missing S arrival at one station would be weak evidence on its own. A particular earthquake can send little S wave energy in a given direction, and a weak signal can be hard to distinguish from background noise. The stronger evidence came from comparing many earthquakes and stations. The cutoff depended on the geometry of the wave path: direct S waves arrived along paths through the solid mantle but disappeared where those paths would have to enter the core.

In the early 1900s, Richard Dixon Oldham used seismic arrival records to identify a distinct core. Later work refined the location of the core boundary and the interpretation of the wave paths. The two kinds of observations work together: P waves show that the core can transmit compression, while the persistent absence of direct S transmission shows that the outer core does not support shear. This evidence applies to the outer core, not to the entire core. Earth also has a solid inner core.

Tracing a wave that changes type

One detail can seem to contradict the shadow zone until you trace the whole path. An S wave in the mantle can transfer some of its energy into a P wave at the outer core boundary. That P wave crosses the liquid, and some of its energy can convert back to an S wave when it enters the mantle on the other side. Seismologists label this path SKS. Each S marks a shear wave leg in the mantle, and K marks a compression wave leg in the outer core.

Try sketching that path alongside a mantle-only S path. Label each leg with both the wave type and the material it passes through. If you use the IESC training and practice problems or earth science learning resources, apply the same habit to other diagrams: explain the behavior at each boundary. For SKS, the key is that a station can record sideways motion even though the energy traveled through the liquid part of its route as compression.

Frequently asked questions

Can P waves travel through the liquid outer core?
Yes. P waves alternately compress and expand material, and the liquid outer core resists changes in volume.

Does an S wave shadow zone mean there is no shaking?
No. It means direct S arrivals are missing. Stations can still detect other waves, including waves that change type at the core boundary.

Why can ocean waves move water up and down?
Ocean surface waves move along a boundary, where gravity helps restore the displaced surface. They do not require the bulk water to act like an elastic solid.

About the International Earth Science Competition: an online earth science competition for high school students from around the world. Qualification Round 2027: submissions are open until Sunday, 24 January 2027. How the rounds work

Written by Julia Berens, Social Media Assistant of the IESC team.

More articles

All articles